There were 129 unmarked graves in Kilmihil Old Graveyard when it was surveyed in 2018 these are listed below.
| – | Number | Section |
| Unmarked | 12 | 1A |
| Unmarked | 27 | 1A |
| Unmarked | 32 | 1A |
| Unmarked | 34 | 1A |
| Unmarked | 39 | 1A |
| Unmarked | 15 | 2A |
| Unmarked | 32 | 2A |
| Unmarked | 14 | 3A |
| Unmarked | 23 | 3A |
| Unmarked | 24 | 3A |
| Unmarked | 25 | 3A |
| Unmarked | 18 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 23 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 31 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 39 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 50 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 52 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 59 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 67 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 77 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 84 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 85 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 87 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 91 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 99 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 103 | 4A |
| Unmarked | 1 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 3 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 19 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 27 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 28 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 30 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 33 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 35 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 37 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 39 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 44 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 51 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 54 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 64 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 66 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 70 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 71 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 72 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 77 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 80 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 83 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 88 | 5A |
| Unmarked | 2 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 6 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 8 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 13 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 15 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 21 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 33 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 42 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 43 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 44 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 45 | 7A |
| Unmarked | 77 | 1B |
| Unmarked | 66 | 1B |
| Unmarked | 84 | 1B |
| Unmarked | 39 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 64 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 91 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 95 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 102 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 106 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 108 | 2B |
| Unmarked | 109 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 125 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 131 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 132 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 134 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 135 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 142 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 146 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 147 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 148 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 149 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 151 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 152 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 157 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 159 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 164 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 166 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 182 | 4B |
| Unmarked | 95 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 98 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 99 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 102 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 107 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 109 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 113 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 114 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 121 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 129 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 141 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 142 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 150 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 160 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 161 | 5B |
| Unmarked | 59 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 61 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 66 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 73 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 78 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 79 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 82 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 83 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 94 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 95 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 96 | 7B |
| Unmarked | 118 | 1C |
| Unmarked | 125 | 1C |
| Unmarked | 128 | 1C |
| Unmarked | 140 | 1C |
| Unmarked | 107 | 3C |
| Unmarked | 98 | 3C |
| Unmarked | 158 | 1D |
| Unmarked | 3 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 19 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 27 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 29 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 30 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 31 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 36 | 8 |
| Unmarked | 9 | 10 |
| Unmarked | 10 |
Kilmihil Community 